Modelica: Over-determined system does not make sense

asked 2019-06-18 13:12:43 -0500

first1
71 ●1 ●4

updated 2019-06-21 12:54:27 -0500

shorowit

10911 ●180 ●9 https://www.nrel.gov/b...

I had a model running successfully until I tried to implement proportional control. The only changes I made were as follows:

Added below model, above equations:

parameter SI.MassFlowRate desiredFlow = 2;

parameter SI.MassFlowRate errorInFlow;

parameter Real kp = 0.1;

Added under equations:

errorInFlow = desiredFlow - sink.ports[1].m_flow;

valveLinear1.opening = errorInFlow * kp;

Deleted under equations

valveLinear1.opening = 0.5;

...So altogether I have 4 variables (valveLinear1.opening, errorInFlow, desiredFlow, kp). I define kp and desiredFlow (2 equations) plus the other 2 under equations = 4. I don't see why I am still getting this error of an over-constrained system (one to many equations).

answered 2019-06-19 11:28:07 -0500

Thierry Nouidui
1507 ●13 ●7 https://nouidui.com/in...

updated 2019-06-23 15:11:04 -0500

Michael Wetter
1695 ●12 ●4 http://simulationresea...

I think you are confusing "variables" and "parameters" here. I suggest to check any Modelica book which explains the difference between those two types of "variables". I will recommend to check the book of Michael Tiller as well https://mbe.modelica.university/behav....

In short a parameter is a "variable" which is supposed to be known a prio-ri. It is similar to a constant and can't be changed in an equation section. This is the reason why the compiler is saying that your system is overdetermined.

You should remove the parameter attribute in front of parameter SI.MassFlowRate errorInFlow

to turn errorInFlow into a variable and make your system work.